This exercise details a significant service failure in 2021 at the in-house bakery of Elite Hypermarket, based in Goregaon, Mumbai, India, involving the accidental sale of puff pastries containing non-vegetarian filling to two strict vegetarian customers. The incident may provoke a social-media backlash and hence threatens to damage the hypermarket's reputation, prompting the store manager to quickly investigate and find solutions that will address the crisis and prevent similar situations in the future. Students will be challenged to apply service-management concepts to address customer grievances, improve operational processes, and communicate effectively with internal and external stakeholders.