個案總覽

With inflation high, a global recession possible, and consumers spending carefully, many companies are concerned about preserving profit margins. In this article, pricing consultant Rafi Mohammed argues that instead of simply adjusting prices, firms should consider adding new ways to charge customers. He outlines 18 different pricing tactics that can be used for various purposes: to accommodate buyers with different usage needs, to appeal to people on a tight budget, to spur purchases by customers who love a good deal, to achieve favorable prices when the value of an offering is uncertain, and to increase business efficiency. Mohammed urges companies to think creatively about whether a pricing convention commonly used in other industries might work for their own product or service. For example, Allstate has borrowed the metering model and introduced auto insurance premiums based on actual miles driven. Mammoth Holdings, which owns more than 100 car washes, offers monthly subscriptions for unlimited washes. Some hotels sell day passes to their pools and fitness facilities. By creating a mix of pricing options, companies are likely to please existing customers and attract new ones.

When an established consumer-packaged-goods (CPG) company introduces a new product, it faces a potentially make-or-break decision: how to brand it. Tying it to an existing brand (as was the case for Cherry Coke and Avon Hand Lotion) is tempting. Customers are more likely to try a new product with a familiar association, and companies have to expend fewer marketing resources to launch it. But the strategy has risks, too: Weak or failed brand extensions can harm the parent company. When the maker of Coors beer introduced a nonalcoholic beverage, Coors Rocky Mountain Spring Water, customers were confused, with some wondering about the alcohol content of the beverage. Sales of both water and beer suffered, and the new product was ultimately discontinued. A new study can help companies make the right branding decision-and shows that those who do will be rewarded with higher returns.

Runza National, Inc. (Runza), an iconic Nebraskan quick-service restaurant chain had saturated its home Nebraskan market, with eighty-two stores across the state. A proud, family-run business, the Nebraskan chain was named after a mouth-watering regional specialty: the Runza sandwich. Also known as a bierock, this savoury bread pocket of Russian and German origins was adapted from a family recipe into the flagship offering. To foster further growth, the Runza team sought to expand the chain across the Midwest and beyond, through options such as company-owned stores, franchising, and ghost kitchens. Equally crucial were the areas in which to expand, with possible markets in nearby Wyoming, Montana, Colorado, North and South Dakota, Minnesota, Kansas, Iowa, and Missouri. Canadian communities also presented opportunities for international expansion. In determining the optimal markets and modes of entry, the company had to consider the effect of local factors on the company’s appeal. Its Nebraskan roots had made it a local icon with a devoted customer base, but the next steps beyond its home state would shape its future. Which states of the United States should they expand into, and was Canadian expansion viable? What market types—larger cities or smaller towns—were the most desirable, and which mode of entry was most feasible?

Marlow is a new menstrual health company that developed the first-ever lubricated tampon for smoother and more comfortable insertion and which aimed to deliver the product through a direct-to-consumer subscription model. During its first year in business, the team of female founders focused on product development, including completing the research and testing required to secure regulatory approval from Health Canada and the US Food and Drug Administration. After successfully raising $500,000 in an angel pre-seed fundraising round, the team was ready to bring its innovative product to market. In preparation for the launch, Marlow needed a comprehensive marketing plan that identified the consumers who would benefit most from the product and who would be willing to purchase it. Key messages and a communications plan had to be finalized highlighting Marlow’s differentiated advantage, and the financial estimate for the first year had be forecast and presented to investors.

Founded by CEO Steve Barnard in 1983, California-based Mission Produce was a leading supplier of Hass avocados with a global sourcing, marketing, and distribution network and $892 million in 2021 sales. Barnard had been influential in the global avocado trade's transformation in recent decades. For instance, Mission's use of ethylene gas ripening for avocados had allowed it to supply consistently ripe avocados to the U.S. market for the first time. Moreover, Mission had established an early presence in key avocado-growing countries, including Mexico and Peru, as they were on the cusp of gaining access to the U.S. and other key import markets. Barnard believed Mission's scale, global presence, value-added offerings, and vertically integrated model gave it many advantages in the maturing avocado market. Yet, he recognized the challenges Mission would face in the years to come. In its supply network, these included political instability, declining cost advantages, and the high cost of land in California. Perhaps most of all, water scarcity and cost were mounting concerns with no obvious fix. Mission recently entered the mango category, which, in the U.S., shared notable traits with the 1990s avocados market: mangos were a relatively minor U.S. product that many consumers did not know how to prepare, and their ripeness was variable at retail. Like avocados, mangos could be ripened with ethylene gas in destination markets, but they were more easily damaged during handling and had a shorter shelf life post-harvest.

Founded in 1950, King's Hawaiian, a Los Angeles-based bakery, operated in the competitive bread industry with an expansive list of rolls and bread, as well as a selection of other baked goods, which varied by region. As the business grew over the years, it had added production facilities and increased marketing. For decades, King's Hawaiian had focused on its core bread products, using occasion-based marketing to target consumers. However, in April 2021, with an ever-increasing market, the company had to decide whether to scale up into a mass-market company or continue to service a niche occasion-based segment by offering its unique sweet bread through in-store bakery and deli departments.

Founded in 2018 by Jake Bullock and Luke Anderson, Cann sold "social tonics," or cannabis-infused beverages. By 2022, the company had several notable celebrity investors and talent partners, had sold over 10 million beverages to consumers, was distributing in six states and two Canadian provinces, and had closed on a $27 million Series A funding round. Moreover, Anderson and Bullock had their eyes set on expanding into New York and New Jersey, both of which legalized recreational sale and use of cannabis in 2021 and appeared to be a promising new market for Cann. However, Cann faced significant challenges to growing the business. First, cannabis was illegal at the federal level in the U.S., and the laws varied across states regarding the manufacturing, packaging, sale, distribution, and use of recreational cannabis. Second, distribution of recreational cannabis was still limited primarily to licensed dispensaries. There were also severe limitations on advertising cannabis, even in states where consumption was legal, and individual media properties and platforms commonly rejected or prohibited advertisements for cannabis products. Finally, Anderson and Bullock were trying to create an entirely new category for cannabis consumption and position themselves as an alternative to alcohol. Could they convince mainstream consumers to integrate cannabis drinks into their social imbibing? How should they allocate their marketing spend to give themselves the best chance of success? Which markets should they focus on serving and how should they position the product?

In January 2022, MitiMeth was a Nigeria-based innovative social enterprise that produces handcrafted products made from natural fibres—agricultural waste and aquatic weeds—that are otherwise considered to be waste or a hazard to the environment. MitiMeth added value to this material by transforming it into well-designed furniture and home furnishings, storage boxes, lamps, kitchen and dinner ware, stationery, and souvenir items. Mitimeth’s initiative of transforming this environmental nuisance into marketable products provided work for more than 600 people from over twenty-five communities in Nigeria. Despite challenges in exporting from Nigeria, MitiMeth had made good progress in reaching international markets. MitiMeth had already gone through several challenges, and the COVID-19 pandemic only added to the difficulties the enterprise had experienced. Mitimeth needed a plan that ensured MitiMeth’s long-term sustainability.

In December of 2020, the head of product development at QualityKiosk Technologies Private Limited (QualityKiosk) was grappling with a significant issue. QualityKiosk provided application quality assurance, business automation, digital experience management, and data analytics services to financial services companies across India. Krishna had to recommend the way forward for the company’s latest product—Anabot, a new information technology (IT) journey analytics platform. The Anabot platform could provide its clients with quick insight about any IT incidents in the client’s technology services. It also provided around-the-clock intelligence to the client’s team handling those incidents. In its first year of sales, the customer journey analytics platform had been adopted by five major clients, generating over ₹20 million in revenues for QualityKiosk. However, between May and August 2020, none of over fifty potential clients who had expressed an interest in the Anabot product had proceeded to make a purchase. For the entire Anabot product team, anxiety was increasing about the future of their product. In an upcoming product review meeting with the company’s chief executive officer, the head of product development would be required to present his recommendations for the future of the Anabot platform.

Spreadsheet to accompany product W28436.

Dietz and Watson (D&W), a family run business that had been operating in Philadelphia for over eighty years, was a key player in the deli meat product market. D&W was concerned about losing market share overall; it was dependent on the aging baby boomer segment and possibly not top of mind for a younger, more progressive demographic. In early 2019, the company’s vice-president of brand strategy had to consider various options for investing the brand’s resources and offer a credible plan to the chief financial officer. What tactics could the company employ? What were the risks of various marketing strategies, and how could the company mitigate those risks? Could a digital strategy help D&W make inroads with the targeted demographic? If so, what would such a strategy look like?

Paytm was India’s first digital wallet service provider. It revolutionized the country’s digital payments landscape, but it was slow to adopt Unified Payments Interface (UPI) payments. The entry of WhatsApp into the digital payments industry on November 6, 2020 intensified the competition in the UPI segment of the market that Google Pay and PhonePe already dominated by focusing on person-to-person (P2P) transactions. With a strong 400-million user base, WhatsApp threatened to be a formidable competitor in the P2P segment. Paytm was in third position in the UPI-based payments market, but maintained a firm hold on the person-to merchant (P2M) segment. Should Paytm continue to focus on that segment or should it expand to P2P, which was a larger market with big competitors?

One of India’s leading stainless steel conglomerates, Jindal Stainless Limited (JSL) specialized in manufacturing flat sheets and coils, specific sections, pipes, and tubes. Abhyudaya Jindal, the managing director of JSL, was recently informed about the growing number of counterfeit products on the market that were adversely impacting JSL’s brand reputation and sales, as well as goodwill towards the company.<br><br>This case explores the challenges faced by Abhyudaya Jindal as he tried to address the issue of counterfeiting in the stainless steel pipes and tubes market. The case discusses various ways a company can battle counterfeit goods and how co-branding can be used as a market strategy. The case also examines how strengthening relationships with channel members can help a brand fight counterfeiting.

One of India's leading stainless steel conglomerates, Jindal Stainless Limited (JSL) specialized in manufacturing flat sheets and coils, specific sections, pipes, and tubes. Abhyudaya Jindal, the managing director of JSL, was recently informed about the growing number of counterfeit products on the market that were adversely impacting JSL's brand reputation and sales, as well as goodwill towards the company. This case explores the challenges faced by Abhyudaya Jindal as he tried to address the issue of counterfeiting in the stainless steel pipes and tubes market. The case discusses various ways a company can battle counterfeit goods and how co-branding can be used as a market strategy. The case also examines how strengthening relationships with channel members can help a brand fight counterfeiting.

In early 2018, Eugenia Kuyda, co-founder and CEO of San Francisco-based chatbot Replika AI, was deciding how to monetize the app she had built. Launched in 2017, Replika was a consumer AI "companion app" developed by a team of AI software engineers originally based in Moscow. Replika allowed users to create their own customized AI avatar and then have free-flowing text conversations back and forth with it, like one would with a friend. Replika had a successful initial launch, signing up 2.5 million users in its first year, however, it was struggling to keep users on its app. Replika's research showed that its heavy users tended to be struggling with a bouquet of physical or mental health issues. Two monetization options were being considered: develop a subscription model for the AI companion app or pivot into a mental health app. The subscription model would offer a host of added benefits for subscribers and could be marketed at a broad TAM of lonely people. The mental health app would combine talk therapy (with the chatbot) with clinically proven therapeutic exercises, and would be targeted at people struggling with mental health issues. On the subscription side, investors were concerned that the app's users did not fit the typical profile of paid app subscribers. Yet pursuing the mental health app would mean venturing into a more regulated market and engaging in more carefully scripted responses rather than the freeform texting of the current app. The firm had been through a series of pivots and was hoping to find a clear path before venture funding ran out.