個案總覽

Spreadsheet Supplement for Case W32285

In January 2022, Nicholas Chen had to decide whether to invest in one of two solar power systems to reduce the energy cost of the manufacturing company, Jamaica Macaroni Factory Ltd.’s (JMF). He could purchase a 100kW solar power system and generate some of the energy JMF used while also selling back electricity to the grid when the factory was not operating, or he could purchase a 230kW system, which would produce more energy but, due to regulatory restrictions, would not sell electricity back to the grid.

Spreadsheet to accompany product W34512.

The case examines how to account for risks associated with loan assets (or receivables) through financial reporting for loan losses (or bad debt expenses) in the context of the adoption of the new accounting standard, Current Expected Credit Loss (CECL) model. CECL required banks to consider future economic conditions and to include forward-looking credit loss estimates in the setting of allowance for loan and lease losses (ALLL). This marked a departure from the previous standard, which is called the incurred loss model. Under that model, credit losses were recognized when it became "probable and estimable" that a credit loss had incurred based on historical data and current economic conditions. The case also explores what banks, regulators, and investors thought about the new method. Both bankers and regulators called CECL the biggest change ever to bank accounting. JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon called CECL accounting crazy. Financial Accounting Standards Board member Hal Schroeder indicated CECL would lead to a safer financial system and a more resilient economy. Investors and analysts were trying to figure out the new CECL method and what impact it would have on financial statements.

Faraaz Usmani, heir to the family-owned Herbo Drugs & Pharmaceuticals, a small private Unani pharmaceutical company in Prayagraj, India, planned to expand the company’s business to other states to cover most parts of India. Before implementing this ambitious plan, Faraaz needed to conduct a feasibility study by applying some popular capital budgeting tools such as net present value, internal rate of return, and profitability index. He first projected the cash flows for ten years with an initial investment of ₹6.5 million financed with 80 per cent equity and 20 per cent debt. He expected sales to grow by 15 per cent annually for the next five years, 10 per cent from year 6 to year 10, and a perpetual growth rate of 5 per cent afterward. Faraaz understood that the estimation of the cost of capital was a key step in his analysis. He discovered that finding the cost of equity for a private firm was tricky because stock return information was not available to estimate beta. The case introduces the basics of cost of capital (i.e., weighted average cost of capital) and capital budgeting. It focuses on the details of how to estimate the cost of equity for a private firm.

Spreadsheet to accompany product no. W34060.

Instructor Spreadsheet to accompany product no. W34061.

This case examines the accounting implications of a customer incentive deal between Plug Power (Plug; an industry-leading manufacturer of hydrogen fuel cells) and Amazon.com, Inc. (Amazon; Plug's major customer). Alexis Reed is an analyst struggling to understand the implications of the negative annual revenue reported by Plug for fiscal year 2020. This extremely rare occurrence was caused by the interaction between the accounting rules for reporting payments to customers and those for reporting share-based payments. Plug incentivized Amazon to purchase fuel cells by offering stock warrants for every $50 million purchased by Amazon, up to a total of $600 million in purchases. Payments to customers are typically a reduction to revenue, and share-based payments with performance criteria must be measured at fair-market value when it becomes likely that the performance criteria will be met. An unexpected run-up in Plug's stock price caused the fair-market value of the stock warrants given as customer incentives to exceed Plug's expectations. Ultimately, the value of Plug stock awarded to Amazon drastically exceeded the invoice price of Amazon's purchases. The setting provides an opportunity to discuss Plug's motivations in offering these lucrative sales incentives, as well as to explore the definition of revenue, the accounting rules and implications for payments to customers and share-based payments, and the role of non-generally accepted accounting principles (non-GAAP) measures in executive compensation and earnings calls. This extremely rare case of negative revenue serves as a dramatic and intriguing starting point for class discussions. This case is taught at McIntire as the capstone case in an introductory master's-level Financial Accounting course and within the revenue recognition module of an advanced Financial Statement Analysis course for undergraduates.

For decades, countries have used reduced corporate tax rates as incentives to attract multinational enterprises, or MNEs. But new G-20/OECD international taxation rules aimed at preventing legal maneuvers such as tax-base erosion and profit shifting to avoid paying corporate taxes will have major ramifications for MNEs by 2024. The authors explain the potential impacts of the new rules and suggest four ways C-suites should respond so that their companies are prepared for the changes.

A business school student was preparing for a stock pitch competition. He had developed an interest in stock held by investor Warren Buffet in Liberty Media Corp.’s Series C Liberty Formula One common shares. His research revealed that a substantial part of Formula One’s valuation was accounted for as intangible assets and comprised, in particular, what was known as the 100-year agreement with the Fédération Internationale de l’Automobile, the sport’s governing body. The student was interested in how such an agreement on paper could be worth billions of dollars and how that translated into value for investors. What factors would—and should—Liberty Media Corp. have considered when attributing a value to an asset such as the 100-year agreement that was ten times higher than its original cost? How should investors view these inflated values for intangible assets such as the 100-year agreement and Formula One’s customer relationships and what would be their impact on Liberty Media Corp.’s earnings and future stock value?

A business school student was preparing for a stock pitch competition. He had developed an interest in stock held by investor Warren Buffet in Liberty Media Corp.'s Series C Liberty Formula One common shares. His research revealed that a substantial part of Formula One's valuation was accounted for as intangible assets and comprised, in particular, what was known as the 100-year agreement with the Fédération Internationale de l'Automobile, the sport's governing body. The student was interested in how such an agreement on paper could be worth billions of dollars and how that translated into value for investors. What factors would-and should-Liberty Media Corp. have considered when attributing a value to an asset such as the 100-year agreement that was ten times higher than its original cost? How should investors view these inflated values for intangible assets such as the 100-year agreement and Formula One's customer relationships and what would be their impact on Liberty Media Corp.'s earnings and future stock value?

Student spreadsheet for product W34754.

Rollins Inc., a listed pest control company on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE: ROL), and former CFO, Paul Edward Northen, were charged by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) with improper earnings management. The charges were based on the company's financial reporting between 2016 and 2018. The SEC alleged that Northen waited the preliminary earnings results were ready, and adjusted the company's accounting reserve accounts to align with the research analysts' consensus EPS estimates, without following U.S. Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (US GAAP), and failed to properly document the basis for his adjustments. Rollins was known for boasting about its EPS record. In late 2020, the SEC's Enforcement Division detected irregularities in the company's EPS results through data analytics. On 18 April 2022, the SEC found Rollins to have violated the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Despite not admitting or denying the SEC's findings, Rollins and Northen agreed to pay civil penalties of USD8mn and USD100,000, and to stop any future violations of their previous misconduct. The SEC investigators, Carolyn Winters and Tonya Tullis, uncovered the series of Rollins' misconduct. What steps could they take to avoid similar situation for at Rollins and other U.S.- listed enterprises going forward?

In January 2021, Indigo Paints Limited launched an initial public offering of ordinary equity shares to list the company on a stock exchange. It was one of the most subscribed public offers in recent times in India. The company was in the business of manufacturing and selling decorative paints. A retail investor from Mumbai, India received an allotment of Indigo shares and wondered if the grey market premium indicated a fair value for the stock. He understood that initial public offerings were generally underpriced, but wondered what the company's intrinsic value actually was. He sought input from his friend, who was an independent financial advisor, to help him understand the value proposition that the initial public offering would bring to Indigo Paints Limited. The two friends consulted all relevant financial statements and began their calculations.

Spreadsheet Supplement for Exercise W31083

In this exercise, students are required to match eleven unidentified companies to the relevant industry group in which they operate, based on the Global Industry Classification Standards (GICS). Students are provided with a description of the eleven GICS and the financial information of the eleven companies. Each company is listed on the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX). While the exercise has an Australian focus, international students should be able to correctly match the companies to their industry due to the generic nature of the industry characteristics.

Spreadsheet Supplement for Exercise W32386

Annie Anthony, the chief financial officer of Liz Motor Corp. (Liz), was attempting to use capital budgeting to evaluate an environmental, social, and governance (ESG) project using all the available quantitative and qualitative information. Anthony had planned an ESG project, which would help the company adopt solid-state battery technology for most Liz electric vehicles and reduce the carbon footprint of electric vehicle batteries by 39 per cent, to improve the company's ESG and sustainability. The technology was so new that Liz would be the first major automaker to use it on a large scale. It would increase sales and the profit margin in the long run but would also require a heavy initial investment to allow Liz to adopt the technology. With all the information needed for a thorough capital budgeting analysis, Anthony believed she was ready to develop a framework to comprehensively evaluate this critical project. She also needed to do ten sensitivity analyses based on ten different scenarios.

Spreadsheet Supplement for Case W32397

Founded in 2005, Vermont Kombucha Corp. (V-Ko) was an early mover in the fledgling U.S. market for kombucha, a drink brewed for its health benefits. Early on, the company captured more than 90% of market share. Under the leadership of its founder and CEO, Joe Williams, V-Ko went public in 2015. On the first day of trading, V-Ko's shares doubled in price, and the company closed the year with a market capitalization of approximately $2.5 billion. However, the company's growth began to slow as competitors entered the market. Though V-Ko's market share began to shrink, Williams continued to set aggressive sales targets that were increasingly difficult to reach. In 2018, the company missed its first-quarter earnings target. The company shifted its control systems and company culture, resulting in pressure on salespeople that led to the use of questionable tactics to meet sales and compensation goals. Following a tip from an anonymous employee whistleblower, V-Ko launched an investigation in 2020 that revealed overstated revenue and overstated inventory stemming from lax internal controls. Stepping into the perspective of new leadership at V-Ko, students will discuss the company's business model, sales practices and employee incentives, internal control systems, and financial reporting issues around revenue recognition (specifically sales returns) and inventory valuation (specifically obsolete inventory). Students will also consider what actions, if any, should be taken against those involved in the accounting scandal and how to improve corporate governance and rebuild trust with investors.