Rose by Any Other Name (HBR Case Study and Commentary)

Tom Rose was about to listen to his marketing head, Cassie Martin, make a major presentation on the biggest strategic initiative in Rose Partyware's history: the launch of a branded line of party ware. Rose had manufactured paper goods for parties and other social events for many years. But Tom had recently spotted an opportunity to break out of the pack: a new printing technology that would improve quality and reduce costs. When Rose test-marketed the new line, consumers loved it, and retailers pledged their support. Tom felt that the new technology would give Rose the edge it needed to establish its own brand, which would, in turn, allow the company to stay ahead of its rivals. In her presentation, Cassie reported that customers loved the brand concept. However, it was going to be more expensive than she had originally thought. And Hank Lewis, Rose's national accounts manager, further complicated matters when he told Tom that one of Rose's biggest customers, Party!, had just decided to offer customers a complete line of party goods under its own name and wanted Rose to manufacture it. The management team is split on whether Rose should launch its own line. Tom needs to decide: What's the best marketing strategy for Rose Partyware? In R0303A and R0303Z, commentators Frank Weise III, Cott CEO; Micky Pant, Reebok chief marketing officer; Stephen J. Hoch, a marketing professor at Wharton; Judith Corstjens, head of Cubiculum Consultancy; and Marcel Corstjens, a marketing professor at Insead, offer advice in this fictional case study.

• Brand management
• Marketing management
• Marketing strategy