Competing Against Free

The "free" business models popularized in the digital world by companies such as Google, Adobe, and Mozilla are spreading to markets in the physical world. How should established companies respond? The authors have found that some are too quick to offer free products of their own. Many more either don't move quickly enough or simply fail to respond at all, even when they have the resources to win a head-to-head battle. Consider the reluctance of almost all U.S. newspapers to counter the attack on their classified advertising business from Craigslist. To determine the level of threat posed by a free-product rival, a company should assess the rate at which its own paying customers are defecting versus how quickly the entrant's user base is growing. Most incumbents can fend off the assault by introducing a better free offering and generating revenues and profits through up-selling, cross-selling, selling access to their customers, and bundling the free product with paid offerings. Embracing free strategies is not easy for managers at established companies. One obstacle is the profit-center structure, which makes it impossible to consider a product's revenues and costs separately. Another is the cost accounting system, which is not good for identifying the actual expense of generating additional offerings. To overcome these challenges, managers can push profit responsibility up, push revenue and cost responsibilities down to separate groups, and step back from the cost accounting system. They may find pricing flexibility they didn't realize they had.

• Competitive forces
• Business models
• Profitability
• Competitive strategy