個案資料
了解個案內容與學習目標，選擇授課教師及使用課程。
Insider Trading Without Cooling Off
內容大綱
In May 2021, the majority shareholder and chief executive officer of Ontrak Inc., a US health care services company, established two 10b5-1 trading plans to sell approximately one million shares of stock he acquired by exercising expiring warrants. Before he began the process to execute the first 10b5-1 plan, Ontrak Inc. had just lost its largest client. Three days into the process for the second 10b5-1 trading plan, the company announced that it was losing another major client. On March 1, 2023, two concurrent insider trading lawsuits were filed against the chief executive officer by the United States Securities and Exchange Commission and by the United States Department of Justice. The lawsuits contended that he sold his stock the day after filing the plans instead of waiting a set number of days, commonly known as a “cooling-off” period. However, the chief executive officer was arguing that a cooling-off period was not mandatory when he sold his stock, insisting that the “government [had] clearly overreached in this case.” He was forced to prepare a defence against two separate lawsuits filed against him.
學習目標
The case is suitable for executive, undergraduate, or graduate courses in any business discipline (e.g., finance, business ethics, management, accounting) to illustrate the legal and ethical issues that company executives and employees should consider when trading in their company’s stock. This case illustrates the distinction between legal and illegal insider trading by discussing the first-ever insider trading lawsuits filed against an insider using a 10b5-1 trading plan, in March 2023. The case facilitates a discussion of the distinction between legal and illegal insider trading. It allows students to formulate best practices for developing a legal insider trading plan as well as an understanding of the tax implications of stock-based compensation plans. After completing this case and participating in the class discussion, students will be able to<br><br><ul><li>recognize the distinction between legal and illegal insider trading and understand why insider trading is regulated;</li><li>determine the tax implications of employment compensation packages that include stock and option grants, such as restricted stock units and non-qualified stock options;</li><li>explain why 10b5-1 plans were established and how the new “cooling-off” periods will affect them; and</li><li>design a 10b5-1 stock trading plan that minimizes the threat of being accused of illegal insider trading.</li></ul>