個案總覽

In May 1999, the CEO of this company (the largest brewer in Brazil) is contemplating a bid for Antarctica, the second-largest brewer in Brazil. The primary motives are to exploit economies of scale and other synergies and to prevent other competitors (mainly foreign multinationals) from acquiring the firm. The tasks for the student are to value the target and buyer, propose an exchange ratio of shares, and generally design the terms of the transaction.

In the late 1990s, the National Railroad Passenger Corporation (Amtrak) faced a rude awakening as Congress stipulated that it eliminate its reliance on federal subsidies by 2002. In response, Amtrak drew up a plan for self-sufficiency, the centerpiece of which was a new high-speed passenger service that, it was hoped, would boost revenue enough to make Amtrak self-sufficient by 2002. To run this new service, Amtrak needed to purchase $750 million worth of new locomotives and train sets in 1999. Three alternatives were available for funding the purchase: debt financing, lease financing, or reliance on federal sources. The case opens with Amtrak's CFO instructing her staff in April 1999 to review a leveraged-lease proposal that has just been submitted by BNY Capital Funding LLC. The objectives of the case are to introduce students to financial leases as a financing alternative, explore the lease-versus-buy decision and the conditions under which financial lease arrangements make sense, and exercise skills in the valuation of financial leases.

In this B case, designed to follow F-1339, the money manager sees that Corning has lowered its forecast for the second time that year. As she reviews the updated valuation she did on the convertible bonds, she wonders if she should sell or continue to hold on to them.

Introduces the weighted average cost of capital (WACC). Provides a WACC calculation, although it has been intentionally designed to mislead students. Thus, their task is to identify and explain the "mistakes" in the analysis, which are intended to highlight conceptual issues regarding WACC and its components. Such issues are often misunderstood by students. Assumes that students have been exposed to the WACC, CAPM, the dividend discount model, and the earnings capitalization model.

Set in December 2000 immediately following the merger announcement between PepsiCo Inc. and the Quaker Oats Company, asks students to examine the implications of the merger for the rivalry between Coca-Cola Co. and PepsiCo, and for value creation by each firm. Because the merger would allow PepsiCo to control Gatorade, which held an 83% share in the sports drink market, PepsiCo would further strengthen its already wide lead over Coca-Cola Co. in the noncarbonated drinks segment. Would Coca-Cola's historically stellar performance in terms of value creation be threatened by the merger?

In November 2000, a money manager needs to make a decision regarding an offering of convertible bonds by Corning. The analysis requires her to compare the insights available from standard descriptive ratios to those available from valuation analysis. This case is intended to be a student's first exercise in analyzing convertible bonds and assumes some familiarity with option pricing theory and bond valuation. In addition, the case highlights the importance of going beyond the convertible bond calculations. The volatility of Corning stock has increased in the past year, and makes the call option more valuable, but at the same time Corning appears to be issuing converts at a time when both its share price and stock market valuations are at historic highs. Thus it is imperative that the student "have a view" on the sustainability of stock market valuations and the outlook for Corning.