In July 2016, the founder and chief executive officer of Tantan, a Chinese mobile dating application, considered the progress made by his firm since its launch less than a year earlier. Tantan had more than two million active users, yet significant challenges remained. The top management team needed to make several important decisions regarding Tantan's target audience, the positioning of the company, and how best to carve out a viable niche in China's fast-growing and increasingly competitive mobile dating market.
In September 2015, the marketing manager of the Advanced Surgical Solutions Division at Medtronic plc (Medtronic), Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA), weighs his options as to how best to respond to yet another instance of "grey marketing," that is, the unauthorized distribution of genuine branded products. The rampant parallel importation of one of Medtronics' best-selling products-LigaSure Vessel Sealing instruments-has resulted in a much smaller-than-usual order from one of Medtronics' most important customers, the King Faisal Specialist Hospital & Research Center. Medtronics' marketing manager must find a way to respond appropriately to the customer without risking the ire of his sole authorized distributor in KSA.
In 2014, Zheng Shan Tea Company, a Chinese tea producer and exporter, noticed an increase in the consumption of black tea, particularly among mainstream, middle-class consumers in China. The company wondered how it could increase its sales and leverage the growing popularity of black tea. The company's brand director recognized the potential opportunities, but realized that she had two significant challenges. First, because the company had historically been positioned as a premium brand, targeted at high-income consumers, it risked diluting the brand by making its tea more attractive to the mass market. Second, the Chinese government, as part of its crackdown on corruption, discouraged the purchase and consumption of luxury goods. The brand director needed to decide what action to take to realize the company's goal of increasing sales.
On March 31, 2014, the vice-president of Sales & Marketing at Xiamen Airlines Co. Ltd. (XiamenAir) was reviewing the minutes of the month-end meeting with his team. The meeting had focused mainly on the rapid spread of high-speed rail in China, especially along the popular and profitable routes served by his company. The new train service might become an indirect, albeit potent source of competition, redirecting existing passenger volume from airlines to a much cheaper travel option. How would its growth affect the positioning of XiamenAir as a premium service, high-priced airline? How should the company respond to this development?
This is an MIT Sloan Management Review article. In recent years, gray markets--in which a firm's products are sold or resold through unauthorized dealers--have become ubiquitous. They exist for tangible products (lumber and electronic components) and intangibles (broadcast signals, IPOs); for massive goods (automobiles and heavy construction equipment) and for light, easily shipped products (watches and cosmetics); for the mundane (health and beauty aids) and the life saving (prescription drugs). Gray markets aren't going away soon. Although they ebb and flow as exchange rates, price differentials, and supply conditions change, surveys confirm the increasing incidence and scope of gray markets. In many situations, their sales outstrip authorized sales. An inability to compete with gray markets can wreak havoc on firms and industries. Unfortunately, because it is so hard to get data on gray market activity and what firms are doing to deal with it, there is little published guidance to help managers. The sale of legitimate products in the wrong place or through the wrong channel poses unique problems to companies. But there are unique solutions that can successfully manage them. Using several examples that show the scope and complexity of the gray market problem, the authors explain how managers can apply a framework based on sensing, speed, and severity to manage it. They also point out scenarios in which gray markets are actually helpful and should be tolerated.