The control of the state-run airline Air India was handed over to Tata Sons on January 27, 2022, by the Government of India. Air India had returned to Tata Sons with a severely dented reputation, being known for bad service, frequent delays, and flight cancellations. Therefore, rejuvenating Air India would be a daunting task. Some industry experts felt that the takeover of Air India was the best chance the airline had of a commercial revival; others were not so optimistic. Despite the lingering skepticism, the chief executive officer of Air India was confident of an effective turnaround. He wanted to capture 30 per cent of India's domestic aviation market in the next five years and brand Air India as the carrier of choice for passengers worldwide. He wanted Air India to compete against world-leading airlines such as Emirates and Singapore Airlines. However, he had some questions to resolve. What strategies should Air India adopt to undergo such a drastic brand repositioning? Could Air India revitalize its brand and become a leader among the world's top airlines?
MedfirstIndia Trading Private Limited was a privately owned e-commerce start-up in India. The firm's goal was to establish a first-of-its-kind medical devices e-commerce platform catering to various underserved market segments, such as small hospitals and independent medical practices. The firm relied primarily on digital channels for branding and customer outreach. However, the founders did not have a structured data-driven decision-making strategy in place despite the wealth of data flowing in through web analytics. In 2018, after three years of operations, the firm closed its doors. The case highlights the challenges of strategizing and managing the digital marketing operations of an e-commerce start-up.
Reeling from the economic effects of closures wrought by the coronavirus pandemic, the Walt Disney Company (Disney) was at a pivotal junction. Even though COVID-19 case counts were rising in Florida, the state government had announced numerous reopening measures and guidelines for theme parks and resorts, indicating the state's desire for businesses to start returning to "normal." On May 21, 2020, the Universal Orlando Resort-one of Disney's major competitors in theme parks-announced that it would be following the guidelines and reopening on June 5, 2020. Consequently, Disney had to decide when and if to reopen its Walt Disney World Resort, also based in Orlando, despite rising case counts.
AI development can consume large amounts of energy, leading to growing concerns about the climate impact of this emerging technology. The authors explain how tactics such as rethinking how much training data is required and reusing already-trained models can reduce energy consumption and lower the resulting carbon emissions from artificial intelligence initiatives.
The case follows innovations by Drishti, a start-up company that uses artificial intelligence (AI) and computer vision to provide manufacturers with granular process data on manual assembly, giving them a system-wide view into their manufacturing operations. The firm was founded in 2016 by Dr. Prasad Akella, Dr. Krishnendu Chaudhury, and Dr. Ashish Gupta, who all had extensive experience in industrial process automation. They prioritized the value of enhancing human potential in an increasingly automated world. Noting the limitations of traditional manufacturing line performance evaluation and process improvement, Drishti Technologies presented new capabilities for real-time monitoring and performance improvements. This case is about entrepreneurs creating a new software in an established industry. The case also describes the core functionality and solutions developed from the new software, value provided to customers, and the strategic business model choices faced by the leadership in moving from start-up to scale.
In November 2023, the board of OpenAI, one of the most successful companies in the history of technology, decided to fire Sam Altman, its charismatic and influential CEO. Their decision shocked the corporate world and had people wondering why OpenAI had designed a governance structure that made such a decision possible. In the last year, the company had introduced ChatGPT, the fastest growing app in history, and achieved a valuation of almost $90 billion. Altman had become the public face of AI and was instrumental in making the remarkable progress possible. Over five chaotic days, the company went through three CEO changes, had 90 percent of its employees almost move to Microsoft, and saw five of the six original members of the board resign and be replaced by two new members. The extraordinary high-stakes saga brought together the combustible mixture of idealism, capitalism, and power in the context of different world views of the promise and peril of the AI revolution. The case traces the history of modern AI, OpenAI's groundbreaking developments, its wrestle with the dual forces of commercial success and ethical responsibility, and finally its dramatic leadership upheaval. By highlighting the challenges of balancing advancing AI technology with protecting humanity's interests, the case offers a comprehensive exploration for educators in leadership, strategy, technology, ethics, and governance.
In their final year of studies, many engineering students in Canada eagerly anticipate reciting their obligation and receiving their “ring” as part of the century-old iron ring ceremony (i.e., the Ritual of the Calling of an Engineer). Most students are unaware of the specifics of the ceremony or its history until they attend it. The Ritual of the Calling of an Engineer has been an important rite of passage for Canadian engineering graduates for almost a hundred years and upholds a culture of engineering that is male-dominated, hierarchical, and elitist, in addition to being implicated in environmental abuse and degradation. Over the last century, the ritual has remained largely unchanged, even in the face of public pressure. As a member of the Corporation of the Seven Wardens, what decision, if any, would you make about changing the Ritual of the Calling of an Engineer?
Mysore Deep Perfumery House (MDPH) faced the challenge of scaling a low-tech business in the incense stick market. Led by Prakash Agarwal and his sons, MDPH secured a substantial domestic market share through competitive pricing and extensive distribution, aiming to achieve a ₹10 billion turnover by 2026. The company had to choose between expanding their core business or diversifying into related or new product lines. Expansion entailed deeper market penetration and product variation, while diversification presented opportunities in sectors like home fragrances or personal care products. The chosen strategy had to align with MDPH's economic and non-economic family goals, considering market dynamics and consumer trends. By leveraging their brand equity and distribution networks while staying true to their values, MDPH had the opportunity to navigate industry challenges and realize their growth ambitions.
Orange Sky Australia evolved as an entrepreneurial non-profit organization offering two primary services for the homeless: mobile laundering of clothes and engaging in genuine, individual, face-to-face connections through conversation. In February 2024, with 73 employees and roughly 3,000 volunteers spread throughout Australia and New Zealand, the company’s recent staff engagement data indicated a decline in well-being metrics since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, despite the strong positive organizational culture. The company’s growth strategy to double volunteer numbers within the next two years created additional challenges for how to recruit volunteer team leaders to manage and oversee daily operations as most volunteers did not want leadership roles.
Rex Geveden and Robb LeMasters, CEO and CFO of BWX Technologies, Inc. (BWXT), were concerned that investors and analysts did not fully appreciate the company's transformation from a nuclear reactor provider to the US Navy and Canadian utilities to a multi-product line firm across some of the most compelling growth areas in the nuclear power and propulsion end markets. They aimed to convey this shift and highlight growth opportunities during Investor Day 2021. The executives wondered whether they successfully communicated BWXT's transformation journey and if the market would value the company accordingly.
Over the course of the 20th century, most of the world's major multinational corporations framed their mission around Milton Friedman's famous mantra: that the sole purpose of the firm is to maximize its shareholders' profits. Recently, however, growing numbers of for-profit firms have embedded and embraced missions that go far beyond profit maximization or commercial gain; missions that include some of the world's greatest and most complex challenges: mitigating climate change, for example, advancing economic mobility, ameliorating racial or gender injustice, and attacking global health challenges such as the COVID-19 pandemic. Yet these are still for-profit firms, operating as commercial entities rather than government bureaucracies or non-profit organizations. So how, then, are they meant to operate? What can these firms measure and reward if profits are no longer their only goal? And what must these firms do differently if they truly seek to change the world? The principles described in The ICARUS Principles: What It Takes to Tackle the World attempt to answer these questions, and to sketch out the characteristics that distinguish more typical firms from those that are actively aiming to tackle massive societal challenges. Based on the first letters of these characteristics, we have assembled a list of six principles and refer to them as "the ICARUS Principles."
This case explores the complexities and challenges that can arise when evaluating a job offer that involves a potential conflict between an individual’s passions and their professional prospects and personal relationships. In January 2023, Stephanie MacLean, a recent business school graduate, faced a challenging career decision. She had received a job offer from Hockey Canada’s Public Relations (PR) division for what she had initially regarded as her “dream job.” However, after revelations in the news regarding the organization’s history of sexual assault, she now had reservations about taking up the offer. While tempted by the opportunity to combine her passion for sports and her interest in PR, MacLean feared potentially alienating her social and professional networks, damaging her personal reputation, and limiting her career trajectory. It was Friday, and MacLean needed to make a decision over the weekend.
Luke Thomas, owner and operator of Healthy Eats (HE), was considering the future direction of the business following an inflow of cash from a silent investor. HE was a meal prep delivery service located in London, Ontario that focused on fueling healthy lifestyles with locally sourced ingredients. Having proven the business model in London, Thomas was considering two distinct growth alternatives: opening a second kitchen in Hamilton, Ontario, or doubling down on securing new corporate clients. Regardless of his decision, Thomas also wanted to revisit HE’s fiscal 2023 marketing strategy to ensure sales projections were met despite a limited budget.
<p align="justify">The Solidarity Fund (the Fund) was established in March 2020 by a business group in South Africa to support the South African Government’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic. By September 2022, the Fund had proven highly effective and helped stabilize the healthcare system, provided economic support to the most vulnerable, and also encouraged the population to get vaccinated. Gloria Serobe, the Fund’s chairperson, was happy to have seen it succeed and complete its objectives. She pondered its future as lockdowns eased and the initial hardships of the pandemic slowly dissipated. The President of the Republic of South Africa personally contacted Serobe and asked that the Fund not be closed so that it could be maintained for future crises. Serobe and the board of directors needed to determine what options were available for the Fund—should it remain dormant or be closed?
In 2023, Deion Sanders, known as "Coach Prime," became head football coach of the University of Colorado Boulder (CU). Sanders was tasked with leading CU's struggling football program, which had only achieved one winning season in the last 15 years, back to glory. Many were excited by the idea of having the two-time Super Bowl champion and Hall of Fame inductee as CU's new head coach, but several questioned whether he had the experience and leadership needed to turn around a team in a highly competitive conference, as he only had two years of college coaching experience. In addition, some wondered whether his "old school" leadership style, which required a high level of discipline and personal accountability, would be effective on today's student-athletes, while others questioned whether his approach was sustainable.
In the late 2010's, 5G emerged as a new standard in communication technology. 5G was designed to enable ultra-reliable low-latency communications (URLLC), massive machine-type communication (MMTC), and enhanced mobile broadband (EMBB) (see Exhibit 1 for a detailed explanation), all while reducing power consumption by 90%. Whereas previous generations of mobile standards such as 2G, 3G, and 4G were deployed by mobile network operators (MNOs) such as AT&T and Verizon and provided broad coverage, the emergence of 5G technology saw the emergence of organizations building their own private 5G networks to provide coverage for a specific building or area.
Two years later, on September 7, 2023, Verizon officially launched their Private 5G network, Verizon's Managed Private Wireless Solution, across all 30 NFL stadiums for the 2023 season. The Managed Private Wireless solution underwent an initial pilot during all five international NFL games in the 2022 season, encompassing the deployment and management of private wireless technology, testing and coordination, and in-game operational support, persisting through the 2023 pre-season. Verizon's Private Wireless network provided on-field, full in-game support for coach-to-coach communications. According to Kyle Malady, CEO of Verizon Business, "In every NFL stadium, coach-to-coach communications will run on a dedicated Managed Private Wireless Solution." The introduction of this solution in NFL stadiums for the 2023 season was lauded by Gary Brantley, Chief Information Officer at the NFL, as a "significant milestone" in the collaboration between Verizon Business and the NFL, affirming the commitment to enhancing and innovating the in-stadium experience. How would the NFL navigate the challenges and opportunities presented by this technological leap? Adopting a Private 5G network introduced a multifaceted dilemma, forcing the NFL to weigh the potential benefits against the risks and uncertainties associated with this initiative. As the NFL navigated the balance between enhancing fan engagement and managing the intricacies of technology adoption and network management, it created a narrative that demanded exploration. The decisions made by the NFL in this context would not only influence the in-stadium experience but also have far-reaching implications for the future of sports broadcasting and fan interaction. Did the NFL correctly navigate its intricate web of challenges and decisions faced by the league and member clubs? Did the NFL correctly unravel the complexities and strategic considerations at the intersection of sports, technology, and fan expectations?
In 2023, sustainable investors faced several challenges. The first was the lack of access to standardized and vetted environmental, social, and governance (ESG) data, and equally, the interpretation of this data into investment-useful insights. Reducing reliance on third-party-generated ESG ratings was also an issue. Another challenge was mitigating the risk of greenwashing. Finally, sustainable investors were also under pressure to stay focused on maximizing financial returns. PortageBay, a sustainable analytics platform that leveraged AI to aggregate and analyze ESG data, was founded to solve these problems. As the platform grew, two clients approached PortageBay for help in ascertaining whether they should include Amazon and Goldman Sachs within their climate and gender-focused exchange-traded fund (ETF), respectively. The founders delved into PortageBay's suite of tools to answer their questions.
Fawn Weaver, as a Black woman and industry outsider in a capital-intensive, highly regulated, competitive and male-dominated spirits industry, successfully overcame numerous obstacles to launch a premium American whiskey brand, Uncle Nearest in 2017, which became the fastest growing and most awarded whiskey brand in America. By October 2023, Weaver announced the company's plans to expand into cognac to support her vision of building the next major conglomerate for alcoholic beverages. However, she still heavily relied on capital and needed to convince new investors that her plans for cognac would yield success.
Eric Hughes, advertising sales manager at Regional Broadcast Network (RBN), needs to avoid a takeover by increasing revenue from ad sales. Currently, ad plans are created for advertisers by combining ad spots from a fixed inventory of shows, making an effort to meet requirements such as a preferred split of prime/non-prime shows and views (impressions) in target demographics. Ad plans are priced using rate cards (RCs) based on industry norms, and are often discounted to meet budget requirements. Revenue is not usually optimized using this system because the RCs do not accurately reflect the value of inventory. In this case, Hughes first creates a model that allocates available inventory (i.e., 30-second ad spots) across 10 representative plans. He performs an optimization calculation that recreates the sequential allocation that his salespeople generate when advertisers approach the network one at a time. Next, he creates a model that optimizes the allocation of ad spots across all plans, assuming all customers request their plans at the same time. Hughes realizes that the bid prices revealed in the sensitivity table of the second model can also be interpreted as the opportunity cost associated with one incremental ad spot in each show. When the sequential allocation model replaces RCs with bid prices, which are dynamically adjusted for remaining inventory and expected future demand as each new customer arrives, the resulting revenue is closer to the value produced by optimizing all plans simultaneously. In the B case, "TV Advertising Pricing at Regional Broadcast Network (B)," Hughes uses the full historical sales dataset to conduct a multivariable regression analysis and better understand what drives the price of a plan. Students are challenged to create their own analysis and rationale, and to develop a guide for pricing each advertiser's plan. This case set presents emerging best practices in maximizing revenues in the ad industry.